Jim Keating began his outstanding athletic career at St Mary's High School in Annapolis, where he was a four sport athlete earning 13 letters in football, basketball, wrestling, and lacrosse. He was selected first team All-State lacrosse in his senior year. At the University of Maryland he started and lettered four years on the varsity lacrosse team. He led Maryland to the national championship in 1955 and 1956, earning first team All-America in those two seasons. He played in the 1956 North/South game, where he scored two goals in the South's 20-10 victory. 

Jimmy Lewis began his illustrious career at Uniondale High School on Long Island where he was a standout attackman from 1960-1962. An All-Nassau County pick for three years, he won the Rutgers Cup and the Outstanding Player Award for Long Island lacrosse in his senior year. During his high school career, his team had 45 straight victories. 

Fuller began his career at Garden City (N.Y.) High School where he lettered four times and was a first team all-star defenseman in 1945 and 1946 in the Metropolitan League. His team won the championship in 1945 and 1946. Bill was captain of his football, basketball and lacrosse teams his senior year at Garden City and also received All-Scholastic Football honors in Nassau County. At Syracuse, Bill switched to midfield and was an All-American three times: second team in 1948 and first team in 1949 and 1950. Syracuse won the Division Championship in 1950.

Wilson L. Fewster started his long association with lacrosse at Baltimore Polytechnic Institute where he was first team All-Maryland from 1942-1945 on Poly's championship teams of those same years. At Johns Hopkins, Fewster played on national championship teams in 1947, 1948 and 1950. He was named first team All-American in 1947, third team in 1948 and honorable mention in 1950. He played for the South in the North/South Collegiate All-Star game in 1950. 

A standout for three years at Baltimore's City College, Alvin "Buzzy" Krongard was selected as an All-Maryland midfielder in 1954. Buzzy went on to Princeton University where he was third team All-America in 1957 and second team All-America in 1958. While at Princeton he was first team All-Ivy in 1957 and 1958 and played on the Ivy League Championship teams in the same years. 

Miser began his lacrosse career at Baltimore City College where he received three varsity letters as a starting attackman from 1954-1956. At the United States Military Academy, Miser earned first team All-America honors in 1959 and 1960, and second team All-America honors in 1958. He was a member of Army's national championship team in 1958 and its Tri-Championship team in 1959. In 1960, he was the captain of Army's team and received the Turnbull Trophy as the nation's outstanding attackman. 

Milton Roberts began playing lacrosse at Annapolis High School in 1935. In 1937 and 1938, he prepped at Severn School, for the U.S. Naval Academy, and was named All-MSA both years. Milt played center on the undefeated Navy Plebe team in 1939, then transferred to Johns Hopkins University where in 1941 he was a member of the Blue Jay's National Open Championship team. 

Clayton "Buddy" Beardmore started his lacrosse career in 1955 at Annapolis High School. He then attended Severn School, where in 1958 he was named All-MSA. At the University of Maryland, Bud was twice honored as a first team All-American, in 1961 and 1962, and was honorable mention in 1960, while becaming the highest scoring midfielder in school history. Beardmore totaled 108 points in goals and assists, a record which was later broken by Frank Urso. 

Joseph Seivold, Jr. began his career in lacrosse at Friends School in Baltimore, where he was selected All-Maryland in 1953 and 1954. During his senior year at Friends, he was part of the 1954 Maryland Scholastic Association Championship Team.